Abby Cohen is pissed. For one thing, her most annoying customer, Seth, has been coming into her cafe every morning. And, as the only Jew on the tourism board of her Vermont town, Abby's been charged with planning their fledgling Hanukkah festival. She puts out a call for help and discovers she was wrong about being the only Jew within a hundred miles. As it turns out, Seth's parents have been badgering him to bring a Jewish girlfriend home for Hanukkah, and if Abby can survive his irritatingly handsome smiles, he'll introduce her to all the vendors she needs. But Abby begins to realize that her fake boyfriend might just be igniting a flame in her guarded heart.